|
It is difficult
to reconcile the ordination of a specialized few members
of the body of Christ to ministry and not others with the New Testament.
The apostle Paul writes, "On the contrary, those
parts of the body that seem weaker are indispensable,
and the parts that we think are less honorable we treat with
special honor... God has combined the members of the body
and has given honor to the parts that lacked it, so that there should
be no division in the body, but that its part should have equal
concern for each other" (1 Cor 12:22-25 NIV). Many diverse
parts, one body, with One Head -- Jesus Christ.
Theology ALWAYS
has practical impact. From a functional standpoint ordination
- particularly clergy ordination - has
led to an unhealthy class system that distinguishes
the clergy from the laity, the "professionals"
from the "amateurs." So Christians go to worship
essentially as spectators and/or recipients of the pastor's show.
Whichever pastor puts on the best show is the church people tend
to migrate toward. It's nothing intended. But we all know that's
how it works in practice.
Richard Lovelace
observes: "It is still true that the model of congregational
life in the minds of most clergy and laity is one in which the
minister is the dominant pastoral superstar who
specializes in the spiritual concerns of the Christian community,
while the laity are spectators, critics, and recipients
of pastoral care, free to go about their own business because the
pastor is taking care of the business of the kingdom."
What are the criteria used to distinguish the professional clergy
from the "lower class" laity? They are (at least in Reformed
churches) primarily academic rather than spiritual. Only
those who attain a high enough level of theological proficiency
and professional competency and pass academic exams by fellow professionals
are qualified for ordination and its exclusive priviledges, including
administering the Sacraments. Historically this has led the institutional
Christian church to a top-down clericalism - the central issue the
Protestant Reformation attacked and tried to change!
Again, Martin
Luther: "Let everyone, therefore, who knows himself
to be a Christian be assured of this, and apply it to himself -
that we are all priests, and there is no
difference between us."
David Watson,
author of "I Believe in the Church", says, "Most
Protestant denominations have been as priest-ridden as the Roman
Catholics. It is the minister, vicar, or pastor
who has dominated the whole proceedings. In other words, the
clergy-laity divisions have continued in much the same way as in
pre-Reformation times, and the doctrine of spiritual gifts and
body ministry have largely been ignored."
Robert Munger
forcefully adds: "In our time it may well be that the
greatest single bottleneck to the renewal and outreach
of the church is the division of roles between clergy and laity
that results in a hesitancy of the clergy to trust the laity
with significant responsibility, and in turn a reluctance on the
part of the laity to trust themselves as authentic ministers
of Christ, either in the church or outside the church."
Or perhaps most
notably John Stott, the highly respected evangelical author:
"I do not hesitate to say that to interpret the church in
terms of a priviledged caste or a hierarchical structure is to
destroy the New Testament doctrine of the church."
We believe every
Christian is ordained by God for ministry within the body of Christ.
This is consistent with the Reformation doctrine of the priesthood
of all believers. It is a goal of Mission: North America to continually
pioneer new forms, systems, and structures of Christian ministry
to better align doctrine/beliefs with practices. For this reason,
we affirm the ordination of all believers to ministry.
(Portions
of the above material referenced from Greg Ogden's "The New
Reformation: Returning the Ministry to the People of God",
which is available in our bookstore at a reduced price!)
|